
Merriam-Webster defines the word avant-garde as – and I quote – “…an intelligentsia that develops new or experimental concepts especially in the arts.” I quite agree. It basically means an art or science at the forefront of its unique field. The infamous Star Trek line ‘where no one has gone before’ wrapped into one. In art, Picasso’s Cubism or Dalí’s Surrealism were such currents, to name just two. Or, if you look at science, early quantum mechanics or the famed theory of relativity would qualify to fill the giant shoes such rich concepts entail. One could be sorely tempted to add AI to those august choices as well. But that remains to be seen.1
And that is why this reviewer ain’t a fan of the denomination ‘Avant-Garde Metal’ for any band out there. It would mean the act is at the forefront of some revolutionary movement, fielding something new. But it ain’t. Or at least, not really.2 With this in mind, let the yellow forest – Thy Catafalque‘s newest piece XIII: Sárga erdő – show its trve colors.
And in many ways, Tamás Kátai‘s newest concoction truly is a work of art. The record reminded me of those times when Steven Wilson decided to shake off the constraints of Progressive Metal and hoof it over to a free-wheeling, cross-style approach, starting with The Future Bites. And I mean that in concept, but surely not in style. Sárga erdő does the same and blatantly goes wherever the ideation takes it. Meaning, the act will take whatever style sample works best for the theme. And that, without doubt, leads to a more laid-back listening experience. Instead of stuffing everything into the cramped confines of a single genre. But style confusion isn’t the only main feature. To spice things up, Kátai hired a whopping 34 guest musicians in different roles. That’s not an unknown feature, but the RMR crew has rarely spotted such an overly massive list. And such a monster can easily turn into the artist’s worst enemy and lead to confusion of biblical proportions. Yet, XIII: Sárga erdő sailed through that kind of stress test with flying colors.
So, all of the aforementioned complexity saddles the avid listener with a wild mélange of black-death-gothic-pop-prog-synth-post with a few traditional undercurrents added for good measure. A delivery oscillating from harshest metal to bland pop rock. And often you’ll find tastily arranged strings and the odd saxophone to break things up some.
Fancy a few examples to illustrate further? Dunnák alatt kék mező3 fields your typical pop rock piece. A ditty as boring and charmless as they come. In contrast, Suhamló éji fák4 turned into a deliciously crafted slice of Gothic Metal with a quiet melancholy seldom heard outside the Amorphis camp. Puszta, named after the famed Hungarian grassland, delivers an excellent load of metallic heaviness, a mix in between Heavy Rock and Death Metal followed by otherworldly, key-driven female vocals.
But there’s more. The RMR crew was forever fascinated by Sirató, a Hungarian lament with its slightly progressive airs. Sárga erdő5, the title track, walks you through its autumnal realm, ethereally led by Thy Catafalque‘s long-time live vocalist Martina Veronika Horváth. Highly progressive, even dissonant, melodic, and almost ethereal, it proficiently uses similar themes to those of Forest Metal specialists such as Ellende. The review wouldn’t be complete, of course, without mentioning Tömbök.6 And how could we resist a fine slice of Black Metal in this sea of different moods and flavors? Apart from the Tull-ish interlude and some weird keyboard solo to boot, that is.
So, has XIII: Sárga erdő truly broken enough new ground to deserve the label ‘avant-garde’? Not really. The music doesn’t exactly explore truly new horizons. Instead, Tamás Kátai got us one of the most mind-boggling amalgamations of different styles and genres that, in and of themselves, take on a life of their own. This is seconded by a quiet mastery and a production that doesn’t gripe. And this leaves the listener with a complex, yet somehow strangely seamless and complete work of art. It takes a lot of minute skill to harness all those complexities and to forge a piece that won’t get lost in too many details. Sárga erdő can be heavy and unwieldy, yet – at the same time – it comes across as flowery, light, and slightly melancholic in different shades of autumnal colors.
Long live the yellow forest.
Record Rating: 7/10 | Label: Season of Mist | Web: Official Band Site
Release Date: 20 November 2026
- And especially judging by the insanely enthusiastic, almost giddy response received from Gemini. It stated being at the crossroads of taking over and redefining the meaning of ‘avant-garde’ for humankind. Scary, this was just a simple inquiry posed to a free weak-tea model. I shudder at the thought of what others can do. -Ed.-↩
- In essence, since the emergence of rock ‘n’ roll, not much has changed. Metal is, in an oversimplified sense, just a derivative, an amalgamation of pre-existing styles. And this continues to this day.-↩
- In English: Beneath the quilts, a blue field.-↩
- ‘Nighttime Trees Gliding Away’ in English, da master tells us.-↩
- Yellow Forest in English. You’re welcome.-↩
- Masses it should mean in English, we’re told.-↩

